How to Save a Failing Marketing Strategy

No Comments
  • 39% of marketing professionals think evaluating ROI is their top challenge
  • 64% of marketers want to know how to devise better marketing strategies
  • Email marketing, event marketing, and content marketing are the top lead generation strategies

Your business marketing plan isn’t just a tool for increasing sales. It’s how your brand will be represented in whatever content you put out, both through your digital efforts and through your personal interfaces with potential customers.

But how can you tell if your marketing strategy actually works?

If something is underperforming, the “make it new” approach—tossing the whole thing to start from scratch—isn’t always the best way to go about it. Even a strategy that fails doesn’t usually fail entirely.

Evaluating your marketing plan’s success takes some time, patience, and a good bit of data analysis, but it’s worth your while! Keep these tips in mind before you go back to the drawing board.

How do I audit my marketing strategy?

Define What Success Means for You

What determines a successful marketing strategy? A good marketing plan doesn’t look exactly the same for any business. You have a unique brand and voice, and you’re addressing a specific need in your industry. So, part of answering this question means defining what success means specifically for your business, and what your goals should be.

There are different components that make for an effective marketing plan. You need to decide exactly what you want to accomplish with each one, and then, alongside the costs, set benchmark parameters to help you keep track of your accomplishments.

Examples of Marketing Components

  • Web Content Optimization
  • Social Media Marketing
  • Email Marketing
  • Paid Advertising
  • Trade Shows & Events

Common Digital Marketing Campaign Objectives

After choosing which components of your marketing strategy you want to track and evaluate, you can narrow down objectives for each campaign. Here are some of the most common objectives of digital marketing campaigns:

Return on Investment

ROI is pretty general, but it’s also the most obvious objective. Increasing revenue from your marketing investment is a key sign that customers are responding and choosing to engage with your brand, as well as purchasing your products and services. Analyze your sales data to see what effect, if any, your marketing plan has had on your profits.

User Traffic

Your website is typically the first point of contact from your potential customers online, so it’s important to optimize web content for search engine rankings through SEO. Your content strategy is important for gaining user traffic and should be informative, relevant, and authoritative for users browsing your website.

User Engagements

User engagements can most commonly come from your social media, paid advertising, and email campaigns in the form of views, click-throughs, shares, and much more. These are a good measure of how potential customers are interacting with your brand, and which campaigns are earning successful conversions.

Customer Response

Earning positive (or negative) feedback from your customer base is one of the easiest ways to get a sense of how your marketing strategy is doing. You can utilize things like:

  • Customer Reviews
  • Social Media Comments
  • Customer Service Surveys
  • Online Polls
  • Mailing List Growth

When you use these avenues to gain customer responses, be sure to ask where and how the customer found your business—whether it’s through social media, a Google ad, or by word of mouth from a friend or professional associate. This can help you determine which marketing aspects are actually being effective.

What is a digital marketing strategy?

How to Audit Your Efforts

You should analyze the success of your marketing strategy by auditing your efforts. That may sound complicated, but it simply means taking each campaign and evaluating its efficiency using the right measures:

Web Content Optimization

Organic User Traffic – The number of people browsing online using search engines who find your website organically (without the help of paid ads).

Bounce Rate – How long a user views a page on your website before going to a different page or leaving your site entirely. Creating quality, on-brand content will keep users on your website longer and will help you make conversions.

Social Media Marketing

Web Traffic – Calculate the users browsing your website that navigated from your social media platforms first. It’s a good measure of how much your social campaigns are contributing to web traffic.

User Engagements – Again, these include likes, shares, comments, retweets, and new follows that are actively “engaging” with your brand. You can learn which platforms (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.) are performing the best for your business.

Email Marketing

Delivery Rate – The number of emails that are successfully delivered to your email list.

Open Rate – How many people actually open your emails and read its content, instead of depositing them into the spam folder, or worse, unsubscribing.

Click-Through Rate – How many people follow the Call-to-Action (CTA) in your emails by clicking any links to your website. This is the goal of a successful email campaign.

Digital Advertising

Average Position – The ranking of your paid ad in search engine results. This is important since you’ll be competing for a rank position with other businesses in your industry who use similar keywords and topics.

Cost Per Click (CPC) – You’ll pay for every click on a CPC ad, but you’ll get a direct measure of how many users are engaged by the ad and will potentially make a conversion.

Impressions & Click Rate – Impressions show how many people viewed your ad, while the click rate determines how many of them followed through by engaging with the ad.

Trade Shows & Events

Leads & Appointments Scheduled – Trade shows and in-office events are not just a great way to increase brand awareness, they’re also great tools for networking, getting new leads, and scheduling appointments with your sales team for consultations.

Promo Items Distributed – Keep track of how many promotional goodies you give out during trade shows and events, and you’ll get a good idea of how many people were interested in your brand and may come back for more.

Saving a Failing Strategy

What’s not working?

If you haven’t gotten the results you’re looking for, it may just need more time to work. There may even be points of your marketing strategy that can be fine-tuned, or reoptimized.

Your customers, partners, and employees are all great sources for feedback, but you may discover that you need to refocus some of your strategies to better target your audience. You can even try testing out different CTAs with A/B testing in order to find out what messages perform the best, diversifying your marketing strategy with creative branding techniques.

Is It Time to Call on a Digital Marketing Agency?

For the best results and a dynamic marketing strategy, a professional team powered behind you can make all the difference. Digital Resource is a full-service agency specialized in all aspects of digital marketing, from custom web design and multimedia content creation to social media marketing and paid advertising. Contact us today to schedule a consultation with one of our internet marketing specialists!

Emily is a graduate from Florida Atlantic University where she studied English and communication. With a background in journalism, she is passionate about writing engaging and informative articles, and has a love for local businesses. Emily strives to assist businesses in building their brand identities and communities through quality, digital content.

Free Internet Marketing Analysis

Our team is ready to review your website, your search rankings, and social media presence. We'll provide you with some tips to help you propel traffic, drive leads and increase revenue.

RSS Test

  • How to Define Your Target Audience January 16, 2020
    Over 70% of marketing strategies miss out on optimizing ads with customer behavioral data 53% of content marketing uses interactive content to generate leads 27% of marketing professionals find budgeting costs to be the most challenging What do job interviews, investor pitches, and digital marketing strategies have in common? It’s not hard to spot. If […]
    Alexandra Gomez
  • Strategies to Get More Traffic To Your Blog January 14, 2020
    Have you created a new blog? That’s great! But creating the blog is only half the battle. You also need to get traffic to it. It is useless to develop fantastic content if no one gets to read it. So it is essential to look for ways on how you can increase traffic to your […]
    Digital Resource
  • Top 10+ Digital Web Design Assets (Both Free and Premium) to Help You Work Smarter January 13, 2020
    When you do simple research for the top web design resources and tools, you’ll be flooded with hundreds of ideas. From one side, it’s great because you get a chance to find a tool designed specifically to help you out. From the flip side, the decision-making process can last for hours and even days. So, […]
    Digital Resource
  • Website Design Case Study | Criminal Defense Attorney January 6, 2020
    As designers and developers, our web team always works to put themselves in the shoes of the intended audience. So, when a local criminal defense attorney with 35+ years of experience came to Digital Resource for a website revamp, we had our work cut out for us. The Problem Our goal was to redesign and […]
    Emily Creighton
  • SEO Case Study | Home Services Company January 6, 2020
    The Problem 0 to 100? Try 1000 to 1! A local home services company was building beautiful outdoor kitchens for luxurious, tropical homes. What they were not building was a successful SEO strategy that would bring in more business. The Strategy Let us paint you a picture. This company could not be found in the […]
    Emily Creighton
  • Internet Marketing Case Study | Oral Surgery Practice January 6, 2020
    4 decades of high-quality service. 5-location oral surgery practice. Hundreds of patients being missed out on. With outstanding care but an outdated marketing strategy, this practice was failing to reach a large portion of their target audience. Looking to build an online presence that would turn leads into real revenue and stand the test of […]
    Emily Creighton
  • How to Save a Failing Marketing Strategy January 6, 2020
    39% of marketing professionals think evaluating ROI is their top challenge 64% of marketers want to know how to devise better marketing strategies Email marketing, event marketing, and content marketing are the top lead generation strategies Your business marketing plan isn’t just a tool for increasing sales. It’s how your brand will be represented in […]
    Emily Creighton
  • Setting Company Resolutions Takes Team Effort – Here’s Why January 2, 2020
    According to a Harvard Business Study, people with goals are 10x more successful People with written goals are 50% more likely to achieve than those without IBM found that 72% of employees don’t understand their company’s strategy Happy New Year! Right now, the next 12 months are shiny and bright – and so is your […]
    Emily Creighton
  • Capturing More Leads for a Small Business December 27, 2019
    46% of Google searches are for local businesses. 56% of local businesses have not claimed their Google Business listing. 75% of enabled users voice search every week.   Every start-up or small local business eventually runs into some obstacles when trying to cast a wider net and bring in more solid leads and customers. Increasing […]
    Tyler Hall
  • 4 New Optimization Trends to Look Out For December 27, 2019
      70% of marketers say SEO is more effective than PPC for sales. 21% of marketers write for search engines. 50% of searches are four or more words.   With the introduction of the New Year coming up, it is a good idea to take stock of what you have accomplished in terms of digital […]
    Tyler Hall

More from our blog

See all posts